![]()
TRENDCALC.NET
Scarcity vs. Abundance, Part 1
They Teach You Scarcity, Then Sell It as Getting Rich.
The plan sounds like getting rich. It’s really about the pie you already have.
One Side Teaches You to Stretch the Pie. The Other Teaches You to Grow It.
Philip Stuart Hammond, Jr., CFP™ November 6, 2026
![]()
One side stretches the pie you already have. The other grows it.
You've seen the pitch a thousand times.
A clean plan. A few weeks. A checklist that sounds like common sense dressed up as a breakthrough. Automate the transfers. Optimize the accounts. Stop sweating the latte. Put the surplus into a low-cost fund. Take responsibility. They say do this, do that, then getting rich is automatic. It's like Ron Popeil's famous "Set it and forget it" rotisserie — that old home chicken-roaster TV infomercial.
Sit with that last word for a second, automatic(ally).
I've been in this business for more than forty years. I've watched Marketing Professionals sell the same conventional-wisdom mindset under a hundred different covers to people who were never taught money in the first place. And when I say Marketing Professionals, I do not mean only the course-sellers. I mean the advice professionals who sell and market financial and retirement plans and services. This can include — CFPs, wealth managers, wealth advisors, planners, brokers, insurance agents, and other fancy-title roles — in addition to the course-sellers. Here's what I want you to see, before we get soft about it later:
They aren't teaching you how to get rich.
They're teaching you how to stretch the pie you already have.
Then they sell that stretch-the-pie work as getting rich, and call the sale a plan.
![]()
The package looks like getting rich. Inside is the pie you already have.
“They teach you scarcity,
then sell it as getting rich.”
How we got here
Most people aren't bad with money because they're dumb.
They were never taught.
Parents often didn't know what to teach. Schools skipped it, or treated it like a one-day worksheet. Churches and communities talked virtue and thrift, which matter, but rarely walked through credit, automation, insurance, an emergency reserve, or how a surplus turns into capital. So a gap sat there in plain sight: adults with incomes, bills, fear, and no map.
Then an industry noticed the gap.
Not one firm. Not one guru. A whole industry. Personal-finance courses and "get rich automatically" programs on one shelf. On the next, financial and retirement plans, packaged insurance solutions, indexes, and the advice professionals who market and sell them — CFPs, registered representatives, financial advisors, stockbrokers, wealth advisors, wealth managers, planners, brokers, insurance agents, plus firms in investing, lending, insurance, and securities, and the talking heads, authors, and academics who keep the conventional theories stocked. I long ago defined that industry on TrendCalc.net. Same average-averaging mindset across a lot of wrappers, sold again and again as if the next cover were the missing key.
That's not an accident of branding. Pie-efficiency scales. It productizes cleanly — as a course, a plan, a product menu. Growing capacity — real abundance work — is messier. So the market sold the part that packaged easily, and called the package the whole story.
Nothing is "wrong" with that curriculum. Hear me clearly. I am not sneering at budgeting. I am not sneering at automation. I am not sneering at paying down high-interest debt, buying the right insurance, building an emergency reserve, or spending on purpose instead of by accident. That work is real. It raises the floor. A higher floor is a design goal worth pursuing — never a promise that losses get smaller, and never a substitute for thinking.
I say that as someone who respects efficiency work for a reason. I am an educated industrial and systems engineering graduate. That training gives you the skills to think and act in terms of finding the most efficient path or system. Scarcity software — planning, automation, budgeting, debt, insurance, reserves, allocation — is important and very helpful. Honor it.
But let's name what that curriculum actually is.
It is the old get-rich-safe, get-rich-slow, average-averaging playbook. Almost everything these Marketing Professionals sell, market, and emphasize is scarcity software and a scarcity mindset: be most efficient with the pie of money and other resources you already have. Limited real investing effort — beyond average-averaging — sits on the abundance side: grow and build the pie.
My problem is with the model, not the people. Most of these advice professionals are decent, hardworking, well-meaning people. Credentials and fancy titles do not decide which side you are on. What you sell, market, and emphasize — and the bar you set — does. I carry the CFP™ mark myself. The mark is not the issue. A set-it-and-forget-it passive buy-and-hold model is.
That is the history lesson in one paragraph. People weren't taught. Marketing Professionals filled the vacuum with pie-efficiency and labeled it wealth. Once you see the label swap, you cannot unsee it.
“People aren't bad with money because they're dumb.
They were never taught.”
The scarcity-software map (diagnosis, not a how-to)
Let's now map what the course-and-planning software teaches. Diagnosis only. Then in Part 2 of this essay series, we will focus on the how-to. And finally, Part 3 will be that abundance side that few truly offer. For now, see the map — then the product layer stacked on top of it.
Big Wins, not obsessive latte-cutting. Hunt the decisions that move the needle — major costs, fees, matches, systems — instead of building a personality cult around skipping coffee. Fine. Still scarcity-side: stretch what you already earn.
The 85% Solution: start now, don't wait for perfect. Perfect is a stall. Still scarcity-side: begin managing the pie sooner.
Optimize credit; stop paying unnecessary bank fees. Use credit as a tool. Switch out of accounts that nick you for existing. Necessary. Still pie-efficiency.
Automate the system so behavior doesn't have to be heroic every day. Systems beat moods. Automation is how scarcity work stops depending on a daily miracle. It does not, by itself, grow earning power or build transformative wealth.
Conscious spending buckets rather than a joyless diet. Allocate on purpose. Keep a real slice for the life you actually want. Better than a starvation budget. Still an allocation framework for the pie you already have.
Aim the surplus at low-cost index funds or target-date funds. Here is where the software leans hardest on the word "rich." Compounding in broad, low-cost funds is real. And still — say it plainly — that is get-rich-slow average-averaging. It is the floor's investment sleeve, not the abundance engine.
Personal responsibility. Own the plan. That principle is gold. It belongs on both sides of the pie — or it becomes a sermon about managing leftovers while never building capacity.
That is the scarcity-software map. Honor it. Use it. A six-week course is one way it productizes; a financial plan and a stack of recommended products are others. Just stop letting Marketing Professionals sell you the map of the basement and call it the mountain.
![]()
They sell you the map of the basement and call it the mountain.
What they sell as the "wealth-building" side
Then comes the second move.
After the scarcity software, these Marketing Professionals also sell, market, or recommend a lot of prepackaged financial products, from insurance solutions to indexes, for commission or fee revenue or both. That incentive diagnosis matters. The fee-structure conversation belongs in Part 2.
Those packaged products share the same conventional-wisdom investing mentality: average-averaging, be passive, buy-and-hold, broad asset diversification, get-rich-safe, get-rich-slow.
Here is the label swap. The industry packages and sells that conventional-wisdom stack as if it were the wealth-building / abundance-side software. It is not. Their so-called wealth-building side is still average-averaging — scarcity-software investing with a richer sticker. It is not abundance work.
Real abundance work — Market Professional work — sees average-averaging index investing as the starting line and the floor, not the finish line destination and the ceiling. Market Professionals think bigger: transformative wealth, a much higher bar, and work named Exponential Alpha Top10 (EA10). That is a strategy brand name — not a performance claim and not a promise of results. The fuller abundance case belongs to Part 3. Part 1 only needs you to see that the bar they sell as the summit is still the floor.
Market Professional vs. Marketing Professional
When it comes to financial and retirement plans, you cannot leave it to just any planner, advisor, broker, or insurance agent. Determine whether your representative is a Market Professional or a Marketing Professional. There is a vast difference.
A Market Professional, as I use the term, is an advisor who can competently and successfully make systematic buy-hold-sell investment decisions.
A Marketing Professional is a financial advisor who is an expert at the marketing and sale of prepackaged, off-the-shelf investment solutions, but who is generally not equipped to make actionable buy-hold-sell decisions.
To the Marketing Professional it is always a good time to buy. Price doesn't matter. Be fully invested at all times; always be a buyer of their "product," whether product or service. Ask if they have a sell discipline and you are likely to hear silence. They tend to only understand buy-and-hold. A dirty little secret in financial services is that "sell" is a four-letter word to many.
Unfortunately, most advisors and planners are not Market Professionals — at least by my definition. The vast majority of these advice professionals are not great investors in the sense I mean by Market Professional.
And it doesn't matter what the fancy title is. A common title is Wealth Advisor. Wealth manager is another. Ask what it takes to achieve that title and you often get nothing of substance. The title should not be construed as an affirmation of competence. It is mainly driven by marketing — not competence, not experience, and certainly not skill.
Do your due diligence. Assess qualities and experience. Determine Market Professional versus Marketing Professional for yourself. Teaching mode, not a shopping pitch: once you see the role, stop confusing a packaging skill with a market-decision skill.
“My problem is with the model,
not the people.”
The kill shot
Here it is. This is the one.
They teach you scarcity. Then they sell it as getting rich.
The industry noticed people weren't taught money. Then it sold the same pie-efficiency software a thousand times — courses, plans, packaged products, same get-rich-safe, get-rich-slow, average-averaging mindset — and stamped "automatically" on the promise so you wouldn't notice that almost none of the work aimed past the average. Then it sold the packaged products as the wealth-building side. Still average-averaging. Still the floor.
OYSIYCUI. Once you see it, you cannot unsee it.
If I had to guess, I would say that a "get rich automatically" pitch — course, plan, or product menu — spends about ninety-plus percent of its ink on allocation, automation, fee-cutting, and passive buy-and-hold packaging, and almost none on building past the average. And that can be seen as scarcity software with a wealth sticker. The sticker is the product. The curriculum is the floor.
I'm not saying the floor is fake. I'm saying the label is doing work the curriculum doesn't earn. Managing the pie you already have is adult competence. Calling that competence "getting rich" — especially "automatically" — is the Marketing Professional move. Once you separate the competence from the label, the OYSIYCUI lands: they teach you to stretch. They sell you the word rich.
Two sides of the pie
Picture a pie.
![]()
One side teaches you to stretch the pie. The other teaches you to grow it.
One side is scarcity work: stretch it. Cut waste. Kill fees that don't earn their keep. Automate the transfers. Build the reserve. Insure the catastrophe. Pay down the high-interest drag. Direct surplus with intention. That side matters. Skip it and abundance talk is cosplay.
The other side is abundance work: grow it. Raise capacity. Build skills, leverage, ownership, and decision quality. Once the floor is in place, aim past average-averaging toward transformative wealth and a potential higher-bar Market Professional lane, including work named Exponential Alpha Top10 (EA10) as a strategy brand, not a results promise. Average-averaging is the floor, not the ceiling. A defensible average is not a life plan — I drew that line already. This series is about why so many people never even see the other half of the pie.
Two caveats, in plain English, because both sides compound and both can fool you.
First: you can only cut so far. Efficiency without a larger pie hits a hard ceiling. That top is work, not a six-week script or a packaged product menu.
Second: earning without systems becomes lifestyle inflation. A bigger paycheck with no buckets, no automation, and no reserve just buys a more expensive version of the same stress. Scarcity work without abundance caps you. Abundance instincts without scarcity systems leak.
So no sneering at the floor. And no pretending the floor is the summit.
If you've already done the scarcity work well, good. Keep it. Protect it. Just notice whether your time, attention, and ambition ever leave that side of the pie. A lot of smart, responsible people spend decades optimizing a pie that never gets much bigger — and wonder why the plan that was supposed to make them rich left them efficient instead of free.
Agency: see it, then choose
You could get mad at Marketing Professionals. Plenty of people do. Anger is a feeling. It is a terrible decade-long plan. And remember — my problem is with the model, not the people.
Marcus Aurelius wrote it nearly two thousand years ago: "The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way."1
The impediment here is a gap in teaching that got filled with productized scarcity software and a dressed-up, fake wealth-building product layer. Fine. Name it. Then act. Conventional wisdom is the factory setting of personal finance and a lot of the advice industry — set for the system's ease more than for your specific climb. A default is a choice someone else made before you showed up.
There is an old military saying I first learned from a Navy SEAL book, with roots in the Army and the Marines: embrace the suck.2 The situation is what it is. Deal with it. The suck here is admitting you may have bought scarcity software labeled as getting rich — courses, plans, packaged products, or all three — and that the hard floor work still has to be done, on purpose, without waiting for the next wrapper to save you.
Part 2 will walk the scarcity principles so you can do most of that floor yourself — and say plainly that good advice is still worth paying for, while saving the fee-structure conversation for that piece. Part 3 will take up conventional-wisdom investing you can run yourself if you settle there — then the abundance case: growing the pie, transformative wealth, and the Market Professional path once the floor is in place.
This part was the diagnosis.
They teach you scarcity. Then they sell it as getting rich.
Now you see both sides of the pie. Don't unsee it.
One of the most important points of all my writing is to open people's eyes, get them the correct lens so they can focus and truly see things as they are, not as what and how others, like a self-appointed expert class or some in-power central-planning authorities, want you to see it.
And there you have it, the next or another OYSIYCUI (Once-You-See-It-You-Cannot-Unsee-It) mic-drop moment of understanding.
Notes
1. Marcus Aurelius, Meditations 5.20, trans. Gregory Hays (Modern Library, 2002).
2. "Embrace the suck": US military saying. Earliest documented among US infantry in Afghanistan, late 2001 (Capt. Benjamin Tupper, Greetings from Afghanistan); first in print, Sgt. Michael E. Murray, 101st Airborne, quoted in The New York Times, March 26, 2003. See Ben Zimmer, Slate, Dec. 13, 2013. The phrase builds on Vietnam-era and Gulf War Marine slang "the suck" and was later adopted in Navy SEAL literature. Paul first learned it from a Navy SEAL book; Army/Marine roots noted for accuracy.
3. Curriculum map in this essay is a genre composite of conventional "get rich automatically" / personal-finance-course-and-planning principles (Big Wins, start-now / 85% framing, credit and bank-fee optimization, automation, conscious spending allocations, low-cost index or target-date investing, personal responsibility), plus a diagnostic product layer of prepackaged insurance-to-index solutions sold as wealth-building. No named course, seller, book, author, firm, or product. Diagnostic only — not a how-to manual and not an endorsement or attack on any specific program or person. The "ninety-plus percent" figure is framed as the author's estimate, not a measured statistic.
4. Financial advice industry framing draws on TrendCalc.net FAQ 6 (industry definition; regulators omitted here) and FAQ 8 (Market Professional vs. Marketing Professional; "not equipped" softening of FAQ wording; no "salesman"; no outcome-promise language). Teaching mode only.
Author Note
This is part of an ongoing series on TrendCalc.net examining how conventional frameworks have constrained real wealth creation — and how a more market professional investing approach can change the outcomes.
At my +60 age, when many in the advice professional business are winding down or fully retiring, I find myself more energized and purposeful than ever. After more than 40+ years as a financial advisor, I’ve made a deliberate shift from the conventional model I was initially taught and had once practiced to one centered on true wealth creation, client agency, and economic sovereignty. I have little personal interest in traditional retirement. Instead, I’m driven to help as many individuals and families as possible reach the “promise land” of transformative wealth — the kind that funds real steps up the ladder of life, higher living standards, and genuine financial independence and economic freedom.
My goal is to equip people with the knowledge, mindset, and decision-making frameworks to achieve abundance and purpose rather than settle into scarcity, stress, and fear of running out. Whether that happens directly through a client relationship or indirectly — by readers gaining the understanding and confidence to become far better investors and stewards of their own capital — the mission remains the same: to help as many others foster greater personal self-sovereignty, autonomy, and the freedom to live life on their own terms. What I’ve learned cannot be allowed to die with me; it must be shared so others can build stronger, more secure futures for themselves and their families.
Important Disclaimer
This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide personalized financial, investment, tax, legal, or other professional advice. The concepts, frameworks, and examples discussed are general in nature and may not be suitable for every individual’s unique financial situation, risk tolerance, or goals. Achieving financial independence, economic freedom, or any level of personal self-sovereignty depends on many factors, including market conditions, personal circumstances, and disciplined execution. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers should consult with a qualified financial advisor, tax professional, or other appropriate licensed professional before making any financial decisions. The author and publisher do not guarantee any specific outcomes and are not responsible for any losses or damages that may result from the application of the ideas presented.
